Automatic cars have never been so popular or accessible. While automatic gearboxes used to be the preserve of only high-end cars several years ago, today you’ll find them on a broad range of vehicles that can match all sorts of budgets.
Here at AA Cars, we’ve got thousands of high-quality automatic cars to browse and you can easily filter them with our comprehensive search tool, too. But there are some things to consider before you go for one - let’s take a look.
| Positives | Negatives |
|---|---|
| Easier to drive – No clutch pedal or manual gear changes to worry about | Can be more expensive – Automatic cars often cost more to buy than equivalent manual models |
| Better in traffic – Makes stop-start driving less tiring, particularly in busy towns and cities | Potentially higher repair costs – Some automatic gearboxes can be expensive to repair or replace if something goes wrong |
| More convenient – The car changes gear automatically, allowing the driver to concentrate on the road. | Maintenance can be costly – Certain automatic gearboxes require specialist servicing and specific transmission fluid. |
| Smooth gear changes – Many modern automatics deliver seamless shifts between gears. | May use more fuel – Some older automatic models are less fuel-efficient than their manual equivalents, although many modern automatics are just as efficient or better |
| Good for new drivers – Removes the need to coordinate a clutch and gearstick, making driving easier to learn | Less driver involvement – Drivers have less direct control over gear selection, although many automatics offer manual or sport mode |
Suitability
Considering what type of driving you do most of all is a great place to start when thinking about an automatic car. For instance, if you’re often crawling in traffic or doing long-distance driving, then an automatic is a great choice as it’ll prove a lot more comfortable to use. Plus, there’s less of a gap in efficiency between cars with an automatic and manual gearbox, so you won’t be penalised in terms of fuel economy if you do opt for an automatic.
However, there are some instances where a manual could make more sense. If you’re often towing, then a manual gearbox will give you better control and could make things easier. If you live in an area with lots of hills, then a manual could help, as it’ll allow you to get the car into a lower gear more quickly. Sports cars are often preferred with a manual gearbox, too, as they give a better sense of connection between car and driver.
Transmission types
There are different types of automatic gearboxes to look out for. One of the most common is a torque converter which is a fluid coupling that transfers power from an engine to an automatic transmission and replaces a traditional mechanical clutch pedal.
Then there’s a CVT, which is often used on hybrids. It doesn’t use fixed gears or cogs, but instead uses a system of belts and pulleys to provide ‘stepless transmission’ without any noticeable changes. CVTs are great around town, but can be a little noisy when you need to accelerate hard.
Then there’s a dual-clutch transmission, or DCT. These have become more commonplace over recent years. It uses two separate clutches to help make gear changes as smooth as possible. These gearboxes are popular in all manner of cars, but the downside is that they can be expensive to repair if they go wrong.
Running costs and reliability of an automatic car?
As we’ve mentioned earlier, cars with an automatic gearbox don’t bring as much of an efficiency penalty as they used to. These days, some cars with an automatic gearbox can sometimes be more fuel efficient than a manual gearbox alternative, particularly if you’re doing longer journeys. However, much older cars, such as those with a three- or four-speed gearbox, will use a lot more fuel than a manual.

An automatic gearbox doesn’t need a replacement clutch as often as a manual transmission but, when it does, it can be an expensive operation. You’ll also need to consider getting the transmission fluid checked and topped up on a regular basis to make sure it’s running as smoothly as possible. Any mechanical issue related to an automated gearbox can turn costly, which is why it’s important to do your research before buying. An AA Vehicle Inspection can provide greater clarity in this area; we’ll send out a trained engineer to take a look at the car and determine whether any faults are present. They’ll showcase their findings via a detailed report, too.
What to check on a test drive of an automatic car:
If you’re heading out on a test drive of an automatic car, then there are some things to look out for that could highlight some issues with the system.
- Jerky gear changes - in a conventional torque converter or dual-clutch gearbox - would be a sign that things aren’t right, and that would be the same if the car hesitates when you accelerate.
- It can be a good idea to try a hill start, too; if the car starts to roll back when you start accelerating, then the automatic gearbox might be on its way out.
- If you’re considering a higher-mileage car, then you might want to check its history for routine automatic gearbox servicing.
New vs used automatic cars
If you’re looking at a brand new automatic car, then you shouldn’t have too many concerns to think about. However, during those first few miles, look out for smooth shifting and if there are any jerky gear changes or difficulty finding a gear, then it could mean that something isn’t right and would need checking out by the dealership.
For a used car, then service history is everything. A regularly serviced car will be in better condition than one which has been left for a long time, so look back through a car’s history to find out if it has been well cared for or not. You can check the Government’s online MOT service, too, and using the car’s registration you’ll be able to see how it fared in previous MOT tests and what advisories - if any - were highlighted. Do a bit of research before you buy, too, to see if the car you’re considering was subject to any recalls related to the automatic gearbox. There might be some known issues, too, and doing a little bit of research beforehand can help discover these.
Updated 03/11/2026
Read Time 5 mins