Skip to main content [Accesskey 'S'] Go to home page [Accesskey '1'] Are you a business customer?

Half of drivers caught out by pothole costs

Unexpected tyre costs catch out nearly half of drivers when potholes strike

  • Only 48% of drivers feel prepared for unexpected tyre costs.
  • More drivers turning to tyre insurance to ease the burden.

10 March 2026

The state of Britain’s roads has without doubt deteriorated following the wettest January in years.

As a result of wetter road conditions, The AA’s expert patrols attended nearly a fifth more (17%1 ) pothole-related incidents than in January 2025, leaving thousands of drivers facing the unexpected cost of a new tyre.

An AA survey2 of more than 13,000 drivers has revealed that fewer than half (48%) of Britain’s drivers feel well prepared to cover the cost of an unexpected tyre replacement and many drivers are turning to tyre insurance products like AA Tyre Cover as a way of easing the burden of these costs.

The survey also showed that only one-in-six respondents (16%) was aware of the cost of a premium tyre, rising to four-in-ten (42%) when it came to the price of a mid-range tyre. Only a third (34%) said they understand the difference between premium and budget tyres.

The AA is urging drivers to understand the true costs and benefits of different types of vehicle tyres, warning that the cheapest option may not always offer the best value or safety benefits over time. While budget tyres can appear attractive due to their lower upfront price, there are important differences drivers should be aware of when compared with mid-range and premium alternatives.

  • Premium tyres, although more expensive to buy, are designed using advanced materials and extensive testing. They generally offer shorter braking distances, better grip in wet and cold conditions, lower road noise and improved fuel efficiency. Premium tyres also tend to last longer, which can offset the higher purchase price across the life of the tyre.

    • Average cost: £1603(205 55 R16)

  • Mid-range tyres often provide a reasonable compromise for drivers looking for improved performance over budget tyres without the full cost of premium brands. These tyres are normally more suited to a vehicle used as a second car doing low mileage on local trips.

    • Average cost: £753 (205 55 R16)

  • Budget tyres are typically cheaper because they are made with simpler rubber compounds and less advanced tread designs. While they meet minimum legal safety standards, they often wear out more quickly and can perform less effectively in wet conditions, particularly during emergency braking or sharp manoeuvres. Over time, more frequent replacement can reduce any initial cost saving.

    • Average cost: £503 (205 55 R16)

  • Run-flat tyres (RFT), which are increasingly fitted to modern vehicles, mainly due to the lack of a spare wheel in many newer models. RFTs are reinforced to allow a vehicle to continue driving for a limited distance at reduced speed following a puncture. The fitment of RFTs can improve occupant safety by reducing the need to stop at the roadside immediately, particularly if travelling on so-called ‘smart motorways’ where it isn’t always possible to find a place of relative safety. RFTs are typically more expensive, can offer a firmer ride, and may not be repairable after damage, meaning replacement costs can be higher.

    • Average cost: £1253 (205 55 R16)

Edmund King, AA president, said: “Tyres are the only point of contact between your vehicle and the road, so keeping them in good condition is vital for braking, handling and overall safety. With pothole damage and rising replacement costs catching many drivers off guard, it’s more important than ever to check tyres regularly and understand the options available.

“Tyre insurance, such as AA Tyre Cover, can provide valuable peace of mind by helping motorists manage unexpected costs and avoid a sudden hit to their household budget.”

The AA advises drivers to consider their driving habits, vehicle type and typical road conditions when choosing tyres, rather than focusing solely on upfront price. Correct tyre choice and maintenance not only improve safety but can also reduce running costs and improve driving confidence.

Drivers are also reminded to regularly check tyre tread depth, pressure and overall condition, including the spare (if your car has one) as even the best tyre will not perform properly if it is worn or incorrectly inflated.

1 AA Pothole Index data – January 2026

2 Yonder received 13,045 responses from AA members to its online poll between the 12th – 19th February 2026. Yonder is a member of the British Polling Council and abides by its rules.

3 Buy 205 55 R16 Car Tyres Near Me | Protyre

Tyre Cover for Repairs or Replacements | The AA