Mini Clubman Cooper S

October 2015

picture of car from the front

Rounded lights feature on a typical Mini 'face'

Ratings

Overall Rating 7Overall rating

Value for money Rating 7Value for money

Space and Practicality Rating 7Costs

Space and Practicality Rating 7Space and practicality

Controls and display Rating 8Controls and display

Comfort Rating 8Comfort

Security Rating 7Car security

Safety Rating 7Car safety


Likes

  • Genuine capacity to act as a family car
  • Adjustable rear seat back brackets allow more boot space
  • Supportive and comfortable seats
  • Unique Mini interior ambiance

Gripes

  • Rear side-hinged doors take some getting used to
  • Restricted visibility due to A-pillars and mirror positions
  • Dull engine noise in relation to performance
  • Needs many costly options to reach full potential

Mini has moved the Clubman into more orthodox territory, giving it a conventional four passenger doors instead of the odd and - for the UK, at least - relatively useless single one on the right hand side. It retains the vertically split boot doors, though, and takes them forward as a unique selling point against volume-selling opposition.

The Clubman can now consider itself a direct rival for compact family cars at the premium end of that market, so the likes of the Volkswagen Golf, the DS 4 and the Audi A3 all have a new rival. Its main differentiating factor is at the tailgate, where two doors open horizontally outwards from the middle.

It is targeted at young families, so there's much more legroom and personal space inside than there is in the two Mini hatchback models. Its long and low profile makes it look quite heavily stretched; a factor exacerbated by the oval fuel filler cover.

Mini has decided to target more mainstream parts of the market instead of the endless niches of yesteryear. Instead of the Coupe, the Roadster and so on the Clubman is an attempt to bring Mini style to buyers who might have previously ignored it on practicality grounds.

Buyers will, as with any Mini, have an extensive range of options and upgrades to choose from, and this car's appeal is similarly dependant on specification chosen. At the basic price the package struggles to compete with other, similarly-sized hatchbacks, but at the premium end of things it offers something more stylish and unusual without being unintuitive.

Our verdict on the Mini Clubman Cooper S

With enough money spent on the specification, the Clubman is a welcome and upbeat alternative to rivals that have become a little too predictable. It doesn't offer the best value for money as a result, though, which will be an important factor for some. The arrival of genuine everyday practicality is very welcome, though, and die-hard Mini fans will rejoice at this cheaper alternative to the high-riding Countryman.

Costs
Costs rating 7

The Cooper S is the thirstiest Clubman in terms of fuel and also costs the most in road tax. Its purchase price is similar to the lower-spec but more economical Cooper D, though, so offers a lot more performance for the price. It may not hold its value as well as diesel models do, but there is traditionally a very strong demand for used Minis regardless of engine choice, reducing the impact of depreciation.

Space and practicality
Space and Practicality Rating 7

The car's relative emphasis on practicality includes front door pocket bins that can hold 1.5- and one-litre bottles of liquid at the same time. The boot, at 360 litres, is smaller than that of the Golf, but can be expanded by leaning the rear seat backs forwards on special locking brackets. Automatic windscreen wipers and headlights are standard and can be supplemented with a heated front screen for a cost.

picture of car from the rear

The Clubman maintains its unique twin-door tailgate

Controls and display
Controls and Display Rating 8

The uniquely Mini interior is a significant factor in why people prefer this brand to others. Rounded and circular shapes are used wherever possible, including for the outer frame for the main colour screen. The main interface is controlled via an iDrive dial on the lower centre console, similar to the one in BMWs. The indicator stalk does not stay clicked up or down when in use, instead returning to centre immediately while the bulbs keep flashing. Historically this has caused confusion but becomes second nature quickly.

Comfort
Comfort Rating 8

Shapely seats do an excellent job of providing back support and comfort. They fit and support backs and sides well for slimmer people, but larger frames might find them a bit too narrow. There is ample legroom for rear seat passengers of less than six feet and with no more than average length legs, but the taller will struggle to stay comfortable for long.

Car security
Security Rating 7

The Clubman has a Thatcham Category One alarm system and an immobiliser. Depending on the model and the options ordered, privacy glass is available around the rear half of the car. It could be argued that the Mini is a more noticeable car than many of its rivals, though. A red light on the roof-mounted radio fin, which flashes when the car is locked, is meant to serve as a warning but could instead draw unwanted attention.

Car safety
Safety Rating 7

A tyre pressure monitoring system is one of the Clubman's advanced safety features. Another is the automatic braking function integrated into the active cruise control system. For a fee buyers can add a head-up display that works well enough but, being projected onto a fold-up plastic screen, can block the forward view a little too much. Upgrading to run-flat tyres will prevent an owner being stranded at the side of the road due to a puncture.

Driver appeal
Driver Appeal Rating 7

The latest generation of Mini chassis lacks the greater part of the verve and liveliness of those that have gone before. It's more stable and settled, which is good for the less powerful models and the diesels, but the Cooper S loses a large part of what set it apart from the mainstream. It feels mature and composed to drive, but not playful. The ride is a little harsh on large alloy wheels, but they are necessary to complete the car's look.

picture of car interior

High-quality materials are on offer throughout

Family car appeal
Family Appeal Rating 7

For young families the Clubman would make a stylish second car. It's not really big enough for pushchairs or buggies and it won't swallow a family of four's holiday luggage for a duration longer than a weekend. It does have Isofix child seat mounts, though, which makes the fitment of compatible seats easier, and the extra rear door now makes it simpler to load a child seat from the pavement.

First car appeal
First car Rating 3

It is more likely that a first-time car buyer will look at the smaller cars in Mini's range, namely the three- or even five-door hatchbacks. The Clubman is definitively a small family car, so unless an older driver is buying their first car later than most would, such a pairing is unlikely. There are also very many Mini hatchbacks on the second-hand market that will appeal to budget-conscious buyers more than a brand new Clubman.

Quality and image
Quality and Image Rating 7

Against direct rivals the Mini does harbour a slightly more special feel, at least in the high-spec guise of the test car. It also benefits from the inherited stardom of the highly successful hatchback, which many Clubman buyers may already know or even own. This car gives drivers who are outgrowing their hatchback something similar but larger to turn to. Its status as a highly customisable Mini will boost its image in a stoic market segment.

Accessibility
Accessibility Rating

Reverting to a conventional layout of two doors per side has given the Clubman a new lease of life in the UK. Previously the car's extra door was on the wrong side, and you had to open the front door to release it anyway. Now, the up to three rear passengers can exit on either side as they see fit - including to the pavement side. The doors are light enough for easy handling and the unique boot door design means that headroom is never an issue when loading heavy objects.

Stereo and ICE (In car entertainment)

There is a suite of connectivity options, from USB and FM radio to DAB digital radio and CDs. The standard stereo features a 'visual boost' feature via the main screen, but for a price the system can be upgraded to a Harman Kardon alternative with more power, if not more functionality. Mini's more basic navigation software is standard on this Cooper S model, but again, it can be upgraded.

picture of car in detail

Circular themes dominate the practical interior space

Colours and trim

With a broad range of colours and the option of a contrasting roof in black or white, the Clubman is as customisable as the hatchback. All look equally good on the car's rounded shape, so buyers can pick according to their taste without fear of making a mistake. On the inside there are some fantastic-looking upholstery and trim options, but most are optional for an extra cost.

Parking

The long body and thick rear window pillars don't affect parking visibility as much as with some other cars, and because the rear end is so flat it's easy to judge where the bumper will be. That's a good thing because parking sensors are not fitted as standard. Upgrades are available at a cost. The Clubman's width is slightly against it for bay parking. At 1.8 metres wide it's slightly broader than most rival cars. The tailgate doors require a lot of space to be left behind the car, though.

Spare wheel

Tyre repair kit supplied as standard, run-flat tyres optional.

 

Range information

Petrol engine options - 1.5-litre (134bhp); 2.0-litre (189bhp). Diesel engine options - 2.0-litre (148bhp, 187bhp). Transmission options: six-speed manual gearbox, plus auto gearbox. Trim levels: Cooper, Cooper D, Cooper S, Cooper SD.

 

Alternative cars

Volkswagen Golf Superb all-rounder but not especially interesting

Audi A3 Conservative looks hide a quality cabin

DS4 Left-field choice offers god value for money and higher driving position

Mercedes A-Class Sporty hatchback suffers from noisy diesel engines



Over 1,200 more car reviews online

All the reports since 1990 are available on this site, just search by make and model below.

Step 1 > Select make Alfa Romeo    Aston Martin    Audi    Austin    BMW    Bentley    Cadillac    Caterham    Chevrolet    Chrysler    Citroen    Daewoo    Daihatsu    Dodge    Ferrari    Fiat    Ford    Honda    Hyundai    Isuzu    Jaguar    Jeep    Kia    Lada    Lamborghini    Lancia    Land Rover    Lexus    Lotus    MG    MINI    Maserati    Mazda    Mercedes-Benz    Mitsubishi    Nissan    Perodua    Peugeot    Porsche    Proton    Renault    Rolls-Royce    Rover    SEAT    Saab    Skoda    Smart    Smart Car    Ssangyong    Subaru    Suzuki    Toyota    Vauxhall    Volkswagen    Volvo    Yugo   

 

October 2015