Mini Clubman Cooper D

October 2007

picture of car from the front

Clubman retains familiar Mini styling from the front, but overall it's longer than the hatch

Ratings

Overall Rating 8Overall rating

Value for money Rating 6Value for money

Space and Practicality Rating 8Costs

Space and Practicality Rating 8Space and practicality

Controls and display Rating 7Controls and display

Comfort Rating 8Comfort

Security Rating 7Car security

Safety Rating 8Car safety


Likes

  • Now more room in the back, if only realistically for children
  • More compliant ride over bumps than hatch variant
  • Excellent engine line-up, especially frugal diesel motor
  • Rear loadspace is surprisingly practical

Gripes

  • Interior design can be a little contrived
  • Cooper D diesel is no fireball performance variant
  • Third door on right-hand side is of limited use for UK, right-hand drive market
  • Rear seats realistically only for children, especially on long journeys

Any manufacturer with a one-car range will tell you that any successes won't last forever. That is, unless your name happens to be BMW. With its resurrected Mini range, the German firm hit the jackpot. And just for good measure, there's a 'mini' estate called the Clubman to keep the hatch and convertible company.

Not everyone will likely remember the first generation Mini Clubman, and for those who don't it was essentially a regular Mini but fashioned in the style of a more practical estate. Second time around and the concept remains the same: a slightly longer version of the hatch sporting van-type split rear doors.

Only this time there's an added feature in the shape of a third door located on the driver's side. This rear door opens out rearwards, but only once the front door has been opened for obvious safety reasons. There are parallels here with Mazda's RX8 and its rear doors, although the Mini only has the one - there is no door on its nearside.

The official line is that engineering issues prevented a door being fitted on both sides. To add fuel to the critics' fire, with the UK being the car's spiritual home, the left-hand drive-centric feature will benefit European and North American drivers the most. That aside, the Clubman does boast a bigger and more practical boot, and one that can finally be described as useable.

In reality, the Clubman is much like the older three-door hatch model. The cabin layout is the same and from the front the car looks the same. You can specify either two or three rear seats at no extra cost however, and the Clubman's ride is noticeable smoother thanks to its extra length and modified suspension settings.

Our verdict on the Mini Clubman Cooper D

Unlike the hatch, the Clubman is likely to be a car you either 'get' or you don't. For those that do, the extra room, smoother ride and more practical boot will no doubt be the deal breakers. The Clubman is still a Mini at heart though, which will mean plenty of attention when you're out on the road.

Costs
Costs rating 8

The basic prices for the Clubman variants might look appealing, but you'll need to add a few options to make them more habitable. As such, the cost of ownership will go up, but this is tempered by the optional inclusive service package. Pay upfront and you can have a few years of cost-free regular servicing. Opt for the Cooper or Cooper D and your fuel bill will also be modest.

Space and practicality
Space and Practicality Rating 8

A little longer than the Mini hatch, the Clubman puts its extra length to good use. The rear seats are now useable - to a point - while the car's boot is a sensible size. The rear doors open out van-style to reveal a flat load bay and the option of folding the rear seats forward. Up front, the car's glovebox swallows a surprising amount of stuff, but the door pockets are on the small side. The centrally located cup holders are useful though, as is the cubby in front of the gearlever.

picture of car from the rear

Clubman's distinctive rear marks it out from the more conventional hatch

Controls and display
Controls and Display Rating 7

Like the hatch, the Clubman comes with all the usual Mini-centric controls. It's familiar fare, right down to the oversize central speedometer. It all works though, and the rev counter plus digital speedo/trip computer mounted on the steering column is a useful addition. The slightly contrived toggle switches further down the fascia remain an acquired taste, but at least the column stalks and audio controls are straightforward.

Comfort
Comfort Rating 8

Although a snug cabin by family hatch standards, the Clubman's interior is well made and insulates you from the outside world better than some more expensive cars. The seats are supportive and two adults can travel in the front without bashing elbows. Road imperfections are expertly dealt with by the car's suspension, although anyone larger than a small child will find the rear accommodation limited.

Car security
Security Rating 7

There's nothing special available for the Clubman, other than the usual alarm and immobiliser combination. Locking and unlocking is via the keyfob, which can also unlock the rear doors separately. For extra peace of mind, a visible deterrent such as a steering lock would be a sensible low-cost investment.

Car safety
Safety Rating 8

It's plain to see that a lot of BMW technology has trickled down to the Mini, which is no bad thing. All the usual safety kit is present, with advanced stability control also available. Airbags abound in the car's cabin, putting the Clubman on a par with more expensive machinery.

Driver appeal
Driver Appeal Rating 9

From the outset the Mini was developed with fun in mind, and as such it's enjoyable to drive - whatever the model. The Clubman's slightly longer wheelbase and more compliant ride ensures a better dynamic performance over poor roads. And, as with the hatch, the most powerful Clubman variant is the most exciting. The Cooper S is very close to hot hatch territory, but with none of the usual performance car compromises: harsh ride, poor fuel consumption, poor refinement. As for the diesel Cooper D, it offers 60-plus mpg and a decent turn of speed.

picture of car interior

Third door opens to make cabin access easier, but only on the driver's side

Family car appeal
Family Appeal Rating 5

Despite the presence of a longer wheelbase and an almost 'proper' boot, the Clubman still falls short as a family car. Carrying a pushchair plus shopping in the boot might be a struggle, and there's the issue of getting comfortable in the back if you're anything but a small child. The third door is useful as it would make attending to a child in a restraint easy, but there's no avoiding the fact it's on the wrong side of the car for the UK market.

First car appeal
First car Rating 8

There's little negative that can be said about the Clubman as a first car. It's easy to drive and park, the various controls are intuitive and visibility is good. The hot Cooper S variant might prove a little expensive to run, but the Cooper and Cooper D models should prove cheaper to fund.

Quality and image
Quality and Image Rating 9

With its hi-tech factory and attention to detail, BMW has ensured that Mini production is to the highest standard. While falling a little short in relation to efforts from Honda and Toyota, there really isn't anything to complain about. Image-wise the Mini range has been a huge success on a global scale. The Clubman only adds to the brand's long-term future prospects.

Accessibility
Accessibility Rating

As with the hatch, access to the front cabin of the Clubman is straightforward. You do sit a little lower than in a conventional supermini, but this adds to the car's sporty appeal. Despite the extra inches in the wheelbase, the Clubman's rear seats are realistically only for children - or adults on very short journeys. The car's third door, located on the right-hand side, sort of helps, but means you will be exiting the car into traffic.

Stereo and ICE (In car entertainment)

The standard equipment works well, but it's no surprise to see various cost options claiming to add to the experience. A CD changer and satellite navigation options enhance the ownership experience, along with steering wheel mounted audio controls.

picture of car in detail

Rear doors open out wide to reveal a practical and useable boot

Colours and trim

As with all Minis, the Clubman exudes the same amount of style. There are various supplementary packs that add various trim improvements, plus the usual choice of upholstery materials. Predictably, bright colours - inside and out- work best.

Parking

Yes the Clubman is longer than the hatch, but this doesn't really pose any major problems. The optional parking sensors help matters, as does the car's light steering. The view rearwards is spoiled a little by the split window, though.

Spare wheel

Runflat tyres fitted as standard.

 

Range information

Petrol engine options - 1.6-litre (120bhp); 1.6-litre (175bhp). Diesel engine options - 1.6-litre (110bhp). Transmission options: six-speed manual gearbox or six-speed automatic gearbox as a cost option. Trim levels: Cooper, Cooper D, Cooper S.

 

Alternative cars

Volkswagen Beetle Another style-led car but one with a fair slice of substance

Ford Ka Compact Ford boasts only two regular doors but is spacious and affordable

Audi A3 Sportback Upmarket 'fastback' hatch is highly sought after and versatile to boot

Peugeot 207 SW Conventional 207 compact estate is practical and stylish



Over 1,200 more car reviews online

All the reports since 1990 are available on this site, just search by make and model below.

Step 1 > Select make Alfa Romeo    Aston Martin    Audi    Austin    BMW    Bentley    Cadillac    Caterham    Chevrolet    Chrysler    Citroen    Daewoo    Daihatsu    Dodge    Ferrari    Fiat    Ford    Honda    Hyundai    Isuzu    Jaguar    Jeep    Kia    Lada    Lamborghini    Lancia    Land Rover    Lexus    Lotus    MG    MINI    Maserati    Mazda    Mercedes-Benz    Mitsubishi    Nissan    Perodua    Peugeot    Porsche    Proton    Renault    Rolls-Royce    Rover    SEAT    Saab    Skoda    Smart    Smart Car    Ssangyong    Subaru    Suzuki    Toyota    Vauxhall    Volkswagen    Volvo    Yugo   

 

October 2007