Renault Megane Sport Saloon Privilege 1.9 dCi 130 FAP

September 2006

picture of car from the front

Familiar Megane appearance greets your from the front

Ratings

Overall Rating 8Overall rating

Value for money Rating 6Value for money

Space and Practicality Rating 7Costs

Space and Practicality Rating 7Space and practicality

Controls and display Rating 7Controls and display

Comfort Rating 9Comfort

Security Rating 8Car security

Safety Rating 9Car safety


Likes

  • Good level of refinement and creature comforts
  • Uprated diesel engines are welcome improvements
  • Premium feel extends to the cabin
  • Ride is biased towards comfort

Gripes

  • Keen drivers should look elsewhere for thrills
  • Saloon design is not as attractive as hatch bodystyle
  • Some minor controls are fiddly to operate
  • Rear load compartment not as versatile as that of the hatch variant

The hatch and, to a lesser extent, the estate versions of Renault's Megane are the ones that attract the most attention. The saloon, on the other hand, is something of a Cinderella model for the French firm. Aesthetically it may not be as pleasing as the other cars, but it does fulfil an important role.

As Renault has made constant but small improvements to its image, it has mirrored this activity in its cars. Although careful to avoid making the car significantly different to other models in its range, the most noticeable changes to the Megane include the new V-shaped grille, slimmer headlights and new front bumper.

The enhancement programme continues inside, with an improved range of trim fabrics available across the range. Details such as the new instrument graphics and soft-touch cabin materials have boosted the car's premium feel.

Another growing area of importance for Renault is refinement, and there's an obvious improvement in terms of fit and finish. Changes have also been made to the car's dynamic performance, although the Megane was never designed to be a Ford Focus rival. The car's electric power steering has been tweaked, but it still lacks sufficient feel to please keen drivers.

New engines complete the changes, with the inclusion of a more powerful flagship diesel engine an important addition. But while these changes are admirable and welcome, it must be remembered that the Saloon variant of the Megane range is very much a minority player. Unlike in the South and East, Central and Western Europe is a small market for compact saloons. The Megane is a practical option, but you do have to sacrifice a little versatility in the load area.

Our verdict on the Renault Megane Sport Saloon Privilege 1.9 dCi 130 FAP

There's no question that this Megane range is light years ahead of cars from the previous decade. Well built, boasting a premium feel to the cabins, safe and well equipped, it's difficult to find any major faults. But as a low cost alternative to a premium saloon, the Megane Sport Saloon falls a little short. In truth it's not quite as stylish as its more costly rivals, but it easily holds its own when up against cars from Ford and VW.

Costs
Costs rating 7

The Megane can be an affordable car, but it's easy to be tempted by the higher priced, higher equipped models. You can balance all this by opting for a diesel variant; Renault's diesels are both refined and frugal. The car's good safety record has had a positive effect on insurance ratings, although the saloon model is hardly a leading light in the residual value stakes.

Space and practicality
Space and Practicality Rating 7

The Megane saloon delivers good head, leg and shoulder room for front and rear passengers, although anyone in the back sitting behind a tall passenger will have to compromise slightly. In saloon form, the boot is a good size, but not as accommodating of odd-shaped loads as the hatch car's boot space. Storage areas in the cabin are numerous, though.

picture of car from the rear

Stubby boot is a necessity but can look less than attractive from some angles

Controls and display
Controls and Display Rating 7

Renault gives far more thought to the styling of its controls and displays than many of its rivals. Everything is easy to read, clearly marked and intuitive. The remote stereo controls are a good example, as are the centrally located ventilation controls. The only slight gripe is with the car's handbrake, which dominates the space between the front seats. The lever could be a more elegant solution, and sometimes requires more effort than anticipated.

Comfort
Comfort Rating 9

The bias here is most definitely towards comfort, with the Megane doing an excellent job of filtering out the majority of road imperfections. It also boasts a comfortable cabin, with supportive seats front and rear. The high levels of cabin refinement are also worthy of praise.

Car security
Security Rating 8

You get the usual package of measures on the Megane saloon, including remote central locking plus an immobiliser. An alarm is available, as is Renault's famous keyless ignition feature, which allows you to keep the admittedly bulky credit car-size key on your person and start the car via a button on the fascia.

Car safety
Safety Rating 9

The Megane range's safety credentials are top notch, and have proven to be a strong selling point. All models are fitted with ABS and Electronic Brakeforce Distribution, with ESP, traction control and tyre pressure monitors also available. Airbags aren't in short supply, while Isofix mounting points are present in the rear seats.

Driver appeal
Driver Appeal Rating 7

The driving experience is good, but it is not as enjoyable as some of the competition. The steering is consistent and light, but lacks feel. However, the car's suspension is supple and cabin noise levels are low. Overall, the Megane saloon is a car that is happier drifting along a motorway than it is being driven hard down a country lane. This is especially true of the diesel variants, with their laid-back power delivery and is compounded by the four-speed auto gearbox's old-style 'slush box' personality.

picture of car interior

Light and airy cabin adds to the car's premium ambience

Family car appeal
Family Appeal Rating 8

On the whole the Megane saloon is a good family car, although the conventional booted format isn't as flexible as the five-door hatch layout. The saloon boot can cope with most things, but awkward items might not easily fit or prove difficult to remove. That said, the rear seats offer plenty of room for growing children, and Renault has a habit of littering its cabins with plenty of cubbyholes.

First car appeal
First car Rating 6

Ease of driving and a high level of passive safety are two obvious plus points. However, the saloon can prove tricky to park and the high power variants could prove expensive to run. First timers might find Renault's Clio or Modus cars more funs and less expensive.

Quality and image
Quality and Image Rating 5

Overall fit and finish should satisfy even the most discerning buyers - the French firm has improved its game noticeably in recent years. Image-wise, the Megane's shape goes some way to create an image of French flair, although the saloon is not as pretty as the hatch or estate variants.

Accessibility
Accessibility Rating

Access to the front and rear seats is straightforward, although the rear doors don't open quite as wide meaning they are better suited to the young and more agile. At the rear, the boot requires little effort to open and shut, but the load lip is a little high.

Stereo and ICE (In car entertainment)

Standard fit is a rather good audio system with fingertip remote controls mounted next to the steering wheel and single-slot CD player. A CD multichanger is available, further boosting the car's desirability. The top-range colour sat-nav system is a good one, and responds swiftly to route changes.

picture of car in detail

Boot is spacious but odd-shaped items won't always fit

Colours and trim

Renault has carved out a reputation for itself by giving all its cars excellent specification levels. Overall, the car is better suited to lighter metallic colours rather than darker colours, which make it appear heavy-looking from the outside. Inside, lighter coloured plastics and fabrics suit it best.

Parking

The Megane saloon's shape isn't always a help when it comes to parking, as the car's stubby boot can make judging the distance to parked cars tricky. The safest option is to go for some parking sensors. Elsewhere, the car's light power steering and good-size mirrors reduce the overall difficulty.

Spare wheel

Space saver fitted as standard.

 

Range information

Petrol engines: 1.4-litre (100bhp); 1.6-litre(110bhp); 2.0-litre(135bhp). Diesel engines: 1.5-litre (85bhp and 105bhp); 1.9-litre (130bhp), 2.0-litre (150bhp). Five-speed manual fitted as standard to 1.4 and 1.6-litre petrols and 1.5-litre 85bhp diesel, all others fitted with six-speed manual gearbox. Four-speed automatic transmission available on 1.6-litre petrol and 1.9-litre diesel. Trim levels: Expression, Dynamique and Privilege.

 

Alternative cars

Ford Focus Good to drive, well built but styled more like a small Mondeo

Volkswagen Jetta A shrunken Passat - well built, stylish and comes with a long list of extras

Volvo S40 Quirky small Volvo is compact inside and out. Not a driver's car but well built

Seat Toledo Unusual styling hides value for money package



Over 1,200 more car reviews online

All the reports since 1990 are available on this site, just search by make and model below.

Step 1 > Select make Alfa Romeo    Aston Martin    Audi    Austin    BMW    Bentley    Cadillac    Caterham    Chevrolet    Chrysler    Citroen    Daewoo    Daihatsu    Dodge    Ferrari    Fiat    Ford    Honda    Hyundai    Isuzu    Jaguar    Jeep    Kia    Lada    Lamborghini    Lancia    Land Rover    Lexus    Lotus    MG    MINI    Maserati    Mazda    Mercedes-Benz    Mitsubishi    Nissan    Perodua    Peugeot    Porsche    Proton    Renault    Rolls-Royce    Rover    SEAT    Saab    Skoda    Smart    Smart Car    Ssangyong    Subaru    Suzuki    Toyota    Vauxhall    Volkswagen    Volvo    Yugo   

 

September 2006